All essays

Essay · 14 November 2026

bell hooks — Love Is Not a Feeling You Can Outsource

Humanity has developed an astonishing talent for talking about love.

We write songs about it. We make films about it. We advertise products with it. We put hearts on greetings cards, T-shirts, mugs, corporate websites and—on particularly ambitious occasions—things that have absolutely no relationship to affection whatsoever.

A multinational corporation can announce that it loves its customers while charging them a fee to speak to a human being.

A politician can speak passionately about loving the nation while treating half its inhabitants as an administrative problem.

And a person can insist that they love someone while consistently ignoring what that person is actually asking for.

At some point, you begin to wonder whether love has become the world's most successful marketing campaign.

The American writer and cultural critic bell hooks was interested in a rather inconvenient possibility.

Perhaps love isn't adequately described by what we say we feel. Perhaps it has to be recognised in what we actually do.

That is considerably more demanding.

And far more interesting.

The woman who refused to make herself the point

bell hooks was born Gloria Jean Watkins in Hopkinsville, Kentucky, in 1952. She grew up amid racial segregation and developed into one of the most influential feminist writers and public intellectuals of her generation.

Her pen name honoured her maternal great-grandmother, Bell Blair Hooks. She chose to write it in lowercase partly to direct attention toward the ideas rather than the author's personal status.

There's a pleasingly mischievous lesson in that decision.

Imagine creating an internationally recognised name and then deliberately making it look as though the printer forgot to capitalise something.

Entire industries are devoted to making personal names appear more important. hooks was asking readers to pay attention to the work.

And the work was substantial.

She wrote about racism, class, feminism, education, family, media, belonging, spirituality, masculinity and love. Books including Ain't I a Woman, Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center, Teaching to Transgress and All About Love challenged the comfortable separation of private life from political structures.

Her central concern wasn't simply whether people held nice opinions.

It was whether the relationships and institutions shaping their lives enabled them to live freely and with dignity.

That question travels remarkably well.

Love is not a permission slip

In All About Love: New Visions, published around the turn of the millennium, hooks challenged the habit of defining love primarily as a powerful feeling.

We can feel affection for someone and still behave selfishly.

We can be intensely attracted to someone and still disrespect their choices.

We can feel protective toward someone and still make their life smaller by refusing to let them decide anything for themselves.

The feeling alone is not a reliable guarantee of good treatment.

hooks drew in part on M. Scott Peck's account of love as a deliberate commitment to supporting growth, developing a framework emphasising care, knowledge, respect, trust, responsibility and commitment.

These are not decorative words.

Care means paying attention to someone's needs.

Knowledge means making the effort to understand who that person actually is.

Respect means recognising their independence, boundaries and worth.

Trust cannot be manufactured by demanding it.

Responsibility means remaining answerable for the effects of our behaviour.

Commitment means continuing to participate when affection is not accompanied by a convenient soundtrack.

Suddenly love becomes less like an advertisement for expensive jewellery and more like an ongoing relationship between actual people.

Which may explain why the jewellery industry prefers the advertisement.

The difference between love and possession

One of the difficult questions hooks raised concerns the way domination becomes confused with love.

A person says, 'I only do this because I love you.'

Then they insist on controlling another person's friendships, money, movements or decisions.

The claim of affection is offered as justification for taking away freedom.

But if love involves respecting another person's humanity, then persistent domination cannot simply be made loving by giving it a sentimental explanation.

This is especially important in families.

Parents may genuinely want to protect their children. Protection is a real responsibility.

But children also develop their own perspectives, preferences and capacities.

As they grow, support must change with them.

A relationship based entirely on obedience may produce orderly behaviour without producing trust.

The same problem appears in friendships, partnerships and caring professions.

Someone believes they know what's best for another person.

They may even have useful knowledge.

But the relationship becomes distorted when that knowledge is treated as permission to replace the other person's voice.

Love does not grant ownership.

It creates responsibilities.

And those responsibilities can involve the unsettling task of listening to somebody who disagrees with us.

The words are lovely. What does the system do?

hooks was not satisfied with the idea that private kindness could solve every social problem.

She argued that race, gender, class and economic power shape the relationships people are able to experience.

Consider a workplace.

Its management can celebrate compassion, connection and wellbeing every Friday afternoon.

There can be posters encouraging kindness in every corridor.

Somebody may even bring cupcakes.

But if workers are routinely humiliated, underpaid or denied meaningful opportunities to raise concerns, the cupcakes aren't evidence of a loving culture.

They're refreshments.

The same applies to institutions that profess respect while systematically excluding the people their decisions affect.

Kind intentions may be genuine.

They are not enough.

hooks insisted on looking at the structures through which power operates, particularly when different forms of oppression intersect.

A person doesn't experience race in one completely separate compartment, class in another and gender in a third.

Real life is considerably less cooperative with filing systems.

People live at the intersections of circumstances that affect their opportunities and treatment.

An ethic of love that ignores those circumstances risks becoming a pleasant slogan available mainly to people who already hold power.

And a philosophy of universal human connection faces exactly the same danger.

You cannot announce that everyone is one and then ignore the ways some people are prevented from participating.

A beautiful statement about equality does not produce equal power by itself.

The classroom as a place where people actually exist

hooks's educational writing is particularly important.

In Teaching to Transgress she developed an approach she called engaged pedagogy, drawing on her experiences as a student and teacher and on the work of Paulo Freire.

She challenged what Freire had called the banking model of education: the assumption that teachers deposit knowledge into passive students.

That model has one significant advantage.

It's terribly convenient for anyone who likes being the person with all the answers.

The teacher talks.

The students listen.

The students reproduce the approved information.

The institution records the results.

And everyone congratulates themselves on successfully processing another group of human beings.

Occasionally some learning happens along the way.

hooks imagined a different classroom.

Students bring histories, cultures, experiences and questions that matter to the learning process.

The teacher brings knowledge, responsibility and expertise—but also an obligation to remain curious.

Learning becomes something created through relationships, inquiry and participation.

This doesn't mean the teacher disappears or pretends to know nothing.

Nor does it mean every opinion is equally well supported by evidence.

A skilled teacher can be knowledgeable and still willing to learn.

In fact, the ability to recognise where another person is coming from may make teaching considerably more effective.

Freedom doesn't mean abandoning structure

There's an interesting tension here.

If education is about freedom, does that mean everyone should simply do whatever they like?

Not really.

A classroom requires conditions that make learning possible.

Safety matters. Attention matters. Accessible resources matter. So does the teacher's responsibility to plan, respond and help students develop understanding.

Freedom without support can become another way of abandoning people.

Imagine announcing to a group of students, 'You are all completely free to learn anything you want,' then leaving the room and heading to the pub.

A stirring philosophical declaration.

An appalling lesson plan.

The more demanding task is designing learning environments where individuality, creativity and meaningful guidance coexist.

Students can pursue questions that matter to them while receiving help to investigate rigorously.

They can disagree without humiliation.

They can participate through different communication styles and different strengths.

They can discover how subjects connect rather than encountering every part of human knowledge as an unrelated administrative box.

hooks helped show why the classroom is never simply a neutral container for information.

The way people are treated while learning becomes part of what they learn.

When kindness becomes control

Now consider another institution: a service designed to support people.

Its employees are passionate.

Its brochures feature smiling faces.

Its mission statement contains the words dignity, respect and empowerment in a very impressive typeface.

But someone using the service makes an unexpected choice.

They want to spend time somewhere different.

They dislike a particular activity.

They communicate in a way the staff haven't learned to understand.

Suddenly the institutional language of choice encounters an actual person choosing something.

And the real values of the organisation become visible.

Does it listen?

Does it examine what the person is communicating?

Does it adapt its routines where appropriate?

Or does it treat the person's preferences as inconvenient behaviour that needs correcting?

This example isn't one hooks herself wrote about in those precise terms. It is an application of her insistence that care and power must be examined together.

The Smiling Monad's approach to support and communication arrives at a related question.

Are we helping someone live their own life—or training them to live the life that is easiest for us to organise?

Those are not always the same thing.

Sometimes respecting someone requires patience, flexibility and genuine uncertainty.

It may involve learning a person's rhythms, understanding unfamiliar communication or acknowledging that our first interpretation was wrong.

A system can comply with numerous procedures and still fail to listen.

And a person can claim to be caring while treating someone else's individuality as a problem.

hooks would give us good reason to be suspicious of the gap.

Self-love isn't a luxury purchase

hooks also challenged the idea that love for oneself is somehow opposed to love for others.

Self-love, as she understood it, wasn't simply admiration for your own reflection or the determination to win every argument.

It involved self-respect, care, knowledge and responsibility.

That distinction deserves preserving.

Modern advertising has developed an extraordinary ability to sell self-love.

Apparently, if you buy the correct skincare product, scented candle, gym membership and luxury holiday, you can finally begin respecting yourself.

Which is convenient for the people selling them.

But self-respect is not a consumer reward.

It involves recognising one's own needs and limits.

A person who cares constantly for others without any regard for their own wellbeing may become exhausted and resentful.

A person who never sets boundaries may find that relationships become increasingly unequal.

And someone who mistakes self-love for the right to disregard everybody else has managed to misunderstand the concept in the opposite direction.

The question is not whether we should love ourselves instead of other people.

It is how to develop relationships in which our lives matter alongside theirs.

Mutuality doesn't require identical needs or equal abilities.

It requires recognition that more than one person has a perspective worth considering.

What about people we genuinely dislike?

This is where every philosophy centred on love encounters a difficult practical problem.

Some people are dreadful company.

They lie.

They manipulate.

They mistreat others.

They behave as though the ordinary rules of human decency were designed exclusively for everyone else.

Are we supposed to love them too?

The answer depends partly on what we mean by love.

If we mean affection, warmth or a desire to spend an entire weekend together, obviously not.

Nobody is obliged to enjoy the company of someone who mistreats them.

Nor does respecting another person's humanity require remaining exposed to abuse.

But if love involves a commitment to dignity and the rejection of domination, then we can oppose harmful behaviour without deciding that the person responsible has ceased to be human.

That distinction matters.

We can demand accountability.

We can establish boundaries.

We can remove people from positions in which they cause harm.

We can challenge institutions that protect cruelty.

Compassion is not the opposite of consequences.

Sometimes consequences are precisely what responsible care requires.

And if someone insists that forgiveness or universal connection obliges you to accept mistreatment, it's reasonable to suggest they try directing that moral enthusiasm toward the person causing the problem.

The trouble with telling everyone to love everyone

There is a potential criticism of hooks's love ethic worth taking seriously.

Love is a powerful moral ideal. But it doesn't automatically resolve conflicts between competing needs, rights and responsibilities.

Two people can disagree sincerely about what care requires.

A teacher may need to make an unpopular decision.

A government may need rules that cannot accommodate every individual preference.

A community may need to determine how limited resources should be distributed fairly.

How does love become a useful guide in those circumstances?

It cannot simply mean making everyone happy.

Sometimes that isn't possible.

And expecting universal affection can become emotionally coercive, particularly toward people who have experienced injustice.

The strongest reading of hooks is therefore not that love removes the need for democratic institutions, legal protections or careful decisions.

It's that an ethic of care, respect and accountability should shape how those institutions operate.

There remains room for disagreement over policy, evidence and legitimate authority.

There also remains a need to measure whether proposed changes actually improve people's lives.

A love ethic should make criticism more serious, not less.

If a policy harms people, a sympathetic mission statement isn't enough.

The outcomes must be examined.

Not everyone starts from the same place

Another question matters especially when comparing hooks with broader philosophies of interconnectedness.

Who gets to define the universal?

Throughout history, the supposedly universal human experience has often been described through the perspective of a relatively small and privileged group.

Others were expected to recognise themselves in the description, whether it suited them or not.

hooks challenged this repeatedly.

Her writing insisted that the experiences of Black women, working-class communities and people excluded from dominant institutions were not marginal details in the story of humanity.

They were essential parts of that story.

This doesn't mean only one group can understand injustice or that every member of a group thinks alike.

It means that knowledge is limited when some perspectives are consistently ignored.

And there's a profound challenge for The Smiling Monad here.

A philosophy proposing one consciousness must not erase the differences through which people actually live.

An interconnected reality should make individual perspectives more important, not less.

Recognising common humanity is valuable.

Recognising unequal conditions is equally necessary.

Otherwise universal unity risks becoming another way for powerful people to tell everyone else that their concerns are unnecessary.

The person beside you

A philosophy of connection is tested not by how grand its language sounds, but by whether love becomes something we actually do.

hooks was not advancing that same metaphysical theory.

Her thinking arose from feminist social criticism, education, personal relationships, Christian and Buddhist influences, and a lifelong engagement with questions of liberation.

But the comparison is revealing.

The Smiling Monad asks what it means to recognise another person as part of an interconnected reality.

hooks asks whether that recognition changes how we treat them.

It's possible to believe everyone is connected and still behave selfishly.

It's possible to speak beautifully about compassion while avoiding difficult conversations.

And it's possible to reject universal-consciousness philosophy entirely while practising care, responsibility and justice with extraordinary consistency.

The philosophy isn't an entrance examination.

A person's treatment of others matters regardless of which theory of reality they accept.

This is one of the most useful things hooks contributes to the conversation: she turns attention away from possessing the correct feelings and toward the work of relationship.

Not necessarily dramatic work.

Listening.

Admitting an error.

Making room for disagreement.

Keeping a promise.

Changing a harmful practice.

Treating someone as a participant rather than a problem.

The place we belong

Later in life, hooks wrote extensively about place, including her relationship with Kentucky and the Appalachian landscape.

Her 2009 book Belonging: A Culture of Place connected memory, race, identity, land and the experience of home.

Belonging is a complicated word.

We often imagine it means finding a group of people sufficiently similar to ourselves that we never feel uncomfortable.

But real belonging can be more demanding.

It may require creating conditions in which differences are not automatically treated as reasons for exclusion.

A classroom can offer belonging.

So can a neighbourhood, a family, a community project or a relationship with a landscape.

Yet none of these becomes welcoming simply because somebody puts the word inclusive on a sign.

Belonging has to be experienced.

Can a person participate?

Can they make choices?

Can they disagree?

Can they be recognised without pretending to be someone else?

These are practical questions.

And perhaps they are among the most useful ways of measuring whether our grand statements about human connection mean anything.

The extraordinarily ordinary revolution

bell hooks died in Berea, Kentucky, on 15 December 2021.

Her writing continues to inspire debates about feminism, education, community and the political possibilities of love.

The enduring value of that work isn't that she finally solved human relationships.

Nobody has.

Not even the people selling ten-step programmes promising to do so by next Thursday.

Her contribution was to insist that love deserves serious intellectual and political attention.

Not simply because love feels wonderful.

Because it can challenge domination, encourage accountability and create conditions in which people experience genuine freedom.

There is an interesting irony in the way we often imagine transformation.

We expect it to arrive as a dramatic event.

A revolution. A spiritual awakening. A spectacular scientific discovery.

Sometimes extraordinary changes do happen that way.

But relationships are also transformed through ordinary actions repeated over time.

Someone begins listening.

A teacher changes the way a student can participate.

A community starts giving people genuine influence over decisions.

A person establishes a boundary that allows a relationship to become more respectful.

An institution recognises that its procedures have been protecting the wrong outcome.

These actions don't sound very cosmic.

They're also precisely the sorts of things through which people's lives actually change.

The Smiling Monad suggests that existence is an infinite unfolding of connected experience.

hooks provides an important test for that idea.

If we celebrate connection but remain indifferent to how people are treated, we've missed something fundamental.

The universe may contain infinitely many mysteries.

There may be unimaginable dimensions, unfamiliar forms of consciousness and possibilities beyond anything humanity has yet conceived.

Wonderful.

But there is also a person standing beside you.

They have an experience you cannot simply assume you understand.

They may see the world differently.

They may need something you haven't noticed.

And they might have something to teach you.

Perhaps love begins not when we announce that everyone is part of one grand reality, but when we become interested enough to discover who the other person actually is.

That's a demanding proposition.

It's also a much better use of the word love than another heart-shaped advertising campaign.

Ben Grey · 14 November 2026

Further reading

- bell hooks, Ain't I a Woman: Black Women and Feminism (1981).
• bell hooks, Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (1984).
• bell hooks, Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom (1994). Publisher: https://www.routledge.com/Teaching-to-Transgress-Education-as-the-Practice-of-Freedom/hooks/p/book/9780415908085
• bell hooks, All About Love: New Visions (2000).
• bell hooks, Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope (2003).
• bell hooks, Belonging: A Culture of Place (2009).
• Berea College, Get to Know bell hooks: https://www.berea.edu/centers/the-bell-hooks-center/about-bell
• National Women's History Museum, bell hooks biography: https://www.womenshistory.org/education-resources/biographies/bell-hooks
• Kirsten Olson Lanier, The Teaching Philosophy of bell hooks: The Classroom as a Site for Passionate Interrogation (2001): https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED453342
• bell hooks, final interview excerpt, The Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2023/07/07/bell-hooks-last-interview/