David Bohm — The Universe Isn't a Filing Cabinet
Humanity has a remarkable talent for putting things in boxes.
We have boxes for physics, psychology, philosophy, education, politics, spirituality and the miscellaneous collection of problems we'd rather not deal with before lunch.
Each box has its own experts.
Each expert has a specialised vocabulary.
And whenever two boxes need to communicate, we establish a committee.
By the time the committee has finished defining its terms of reference, the original problem has usually wandered off and become something considerably worse.
David Bohm had a different concern.
What if our habit of dividing reality into independently existing pieces is not simply an innocent way of organising knowledge?
What if, in certain circumstances, it prevents us from seeing what is actually happening?
And what if the same habit that fragments our picture of the physical universe also fragments our thinking, our institutions and our relationships?
That is an enormous claim.
Which is fortunate, because Bohm wasn't a man especially frightened by enormous questions.
A physicist who kept asking the awkward question
David Joseph Bohm was born in Pennsylvania in 1917. He studied physics, worked with J. Robert Oppenheimer at Berkeley and became an important contributor to theoretical physics.
His early research involved plasma physics and collective behaviour: situations in which understanding the behaviour of many charged particles requires more than considering each one separately.
Already, the whole was refusing to behave like a tidy pile of independent parts.
Bohm went on to Princeton, wrote a major textbook on quantum theory and discussed foundational questions with Albert Einstein.
But the Cold War had other plans.
During the anti-communist investigations of the early 1950s, Bohm was caught up in the political persecution of scientists and intellectuals. He faced a contempt-of-Congress case after refusing to answer questions before the House Un-American Activities Committee; he was acquitted, but his position at Princeton was not renewed.
He left the United States, worked in Brazil and Israel, then settled in Britain, eventually becoming professor of theoretical physics at Birkbeck College in London.
The history is worth remembering.
A society can celebrate scientific discovery while punishing people whose ideas or associations make its authorities uncomfortable.
We've managed to invent institutions devoted to discovering truth and then occasionally demanded that their occupants avoid asking particular questions.
An impressive administrative achievement.
Bohm's intellectual life continued. So did the awkward questions.
Quantum mechanics works. So what's the problem?
By the middle of the twentieth century, quantum mechanics had become one of the great achievements of science.
It provided extraordinary predictions about atoms, electrons, light and other physical phenomena.
Its mathematical methods worked.
They still do.
But agreement about the predictions did not produce complete agreement about what the mathematics says reality is.
Does the wave function describe a physical thing, information about a system, or something else?
What happens in a measurement?
Is quantum indeterminacy fundamental?
Can we describe definite particle behaviour beneath the probabilities?
Some physicists considered such questions unnecessary.
If the calculations produced correct results, why demand a story about what was happening underneath?
Bohm wanted to investigate anyway.
A successful mathematical recipe is valuable.
But knowing how to make a prediction is not necessarily the same as understanding what sort of world makes the prediction possible.
That difference fascinated him.
And in 1952 he proposed a version of quantum theory that challenged the belief that a more definite account of particle behaviour was impossible.
The pilot wave and the particle
The approach now called Bohmian mechanics, or de Broglie–Bohm theory, has roots in Louis de Broglie's work in 1927 and Bohm's 1952 development of the idea.
In a simplified version, a particle has an actual position while a wave function helps determine how it moves.
The wave function evolves according to the familiar Schrödinger equation, and a further guiding equation specifies particle motion.
Under the usual quantum-equilibrium assumptions, the theory reproduces the empirical predictions of ordinary nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.
So this was not a demonstration that established quantum physics was wrong.
It was a demonstration that more than one serious account of what the physics means was available.
Think about the importance of that.
A scientific theory can be extraordinarily successful while leaving room for disagreement about its underlying interpretation.
The mathematical results don't automatically settle every philosophical question raised by them.
There is also a complication Bohm's theory makes especially visible: the description of multiple particles can involve nonlocal dependence on the larger configuration.
What happens to one part of a system cannot always be understood by considering only that part in isolation.
This is not permission to communicate faster than light by wishing very hard, and it is certainly not proof that human minds can exchange telepathic messages.
Quantum nonlocality is a carefully defined feature of physical theories.
The universe is mysterious enough without turning every mathematical difficulty into a personal psychic superpower.
The other discovery that really mattered
Bohm also collaborated with physicist Yakir Aharonov on a striking result published in 1959.
In quantum physics, the electromagnetic potential can have measurable consequences even where particles travel through regions with essentially no electromagnetic field acting directly on them.
In the proposed experiment, electrons pass along two paths surrounding a region containing magnetic flux. A relative shift in their quantum phases changes the interference pattern when those paths are recombined.
The effect became known as the Aharonov–Bohm effect.
It was eventually established experimentally and remains an important part of quantum physics.
Why mention it here?
Because it illustrates how mathematical structures that once looked like convenient bookkeeping can possess deeper physical significance than expected.
But we have to keep the claims separate.
The Aharonov–Bohm effect is real physics.
It does not establish that the universe is conscious.
It does not prove the implicate order as Bohm later imagined it.
And it doesn't show that every coincidence in your life is evidence of hidden cosmic communication.
It shows something fascinating about quantum theory.
That's quite enough.
The poor experiment deserves to keep its actual meaning rather than being drafted into every spiritual argument on the internet.
The deeper order Bohm imagined
Bohm's interests eventually extended beyond a particular interpretation of quantum mechanics.
In Wholeness and the Implicate Order, published in 1980, he explored the possibility that familiar, separate-looking objects emerge within a deeper, dynamically connected order.
He distinguished between the explicate order, in which things appear as identifiable, relatively separate objects, and the implicate order, in which relationships and patterns are enfolded within a larger whole.
The terms can sound intimidating.
Fortunately, Bohm liked examples.
Imagine placing a small drop of dye in a very viscous liquid.
You slowly rotate the apparatus.
The dye stretches into finer and finer threads until the original drop seems to disappear.
Now reverse the motion under suitably controlled conditions.
The pattern can gather back toward its original form.
The dye wasn't annihilated and then recreated by a supernatural force.
Information about its arrangement remained distributed through the liquid's structure.
Bohm used this as an analogy for enfolding and unfolding.
It is a brilliant image.
And it is still an analogy.
The apparatus does not demonstrate that galaxies are secretly stored in a cosmic jar of syrup.
Although that would make the universe considerably more interesting at breakfast.
The point is that order can exist in forms we don't immediately recognise from the surface appearance.
Something can look scattered while retaining a deeper organisation.
The universe is not literally a hologram because we say so
Bohm also used the hologram to illustrate his ideas.
In conventional photography, a particular part of an image corresponds to a relatively local part of the object being pictured.
A hologram records interference patterns in a different manner.
A portion of a holographic recording can contain information contributing to a representation of the whole scene, although with reduced detail and under relevant physical conditions.
The image helped Bohm imagine an order in which the relation between whole and part is more intricate than a mechanical collection of little independent objects.
It is tempting to take the next step and declare that the universe has therefore been scientifically proven to be a giant hologram, perhaps operated by someone with exceptional computer equipment.
Please don't.
A useful analogy is not the same as an experimental demonstration of the thing it illustrates.
Even Bohm acknowledged limitations in his examples.
His broader implicate-order proposal remains an ambitious physical-philosophical framework, not a universally established replacement for standard cosmology or a proof of one universal mind.
This distinction matters particularly for The Smiling Monad.
A philosophical idea shouldn't need borrowed scientific authority to be worth discussing.
We can investigate whether two accounts illuminate one another without pretending that either has confirmed the other.
The holomovement: nothing is standing still
Bohm used the word holomovement for his vision of an undivided, continuously active process from which relatively stable things emerge.
Rather than imagining the universe as a warehouse of objects, he encouraged us to think in terms of movement and changing patterns.
A whirlpool offers a useful everyday comparison.
We can point to it.
We can describe its shape and measure its movement.
For a time, it seems like an identifiable thing.
Yet it exists through the ongoing movement of water.
Stop the process and there is no whirlpool to put in a museum.
A flame is similar.
A flame retains a recognisable form while fuel, oxygen and reaction products are constantly changing.
And a human being is not physically composed of exactly the same material throughout life.
We remain recognisable individuals within a history of continuous biological change.
These are ordinary examples, not proof of Bohm's ultimate ontology.
But they make an important point about our language.
We frequently describe dynamic processes as though they were unchanging objects.
Sometimes that's useful.
Sometimes it causes confusion.
The river is not merely a blue line on a map.
The friendship is not merely a category in a phone's contact list.
And reality may not be adequately understood as a collection of frozen nouns.
Thought is also part of the mess
Bohm's concern with fragmentation did not stop at physics.
He became interested in how thought constructs divisions and then forgets that it has constructed them.
We separate nations, disciplines, identities, institutions and social groups into categories.
Some of those distinctions are essential.
We need to distinguish medicine from plumbing, for instance, although certain government renovations might suggest the departments have occasionally been confused.
The problem arises when our categories begin to look more fundamental than the relationships they describe.
Imagine a person receiving support from several professionals.
One worker attends to physical wellbeing.
Another looks at communication.
A third addresses behaviour.
Someone else considers transport or community participation.
Each may have a useful area of expertise.
But the person receiving the support doesn't experience life as four separate administrative programmes.
They have one lived day.
An uncomfortable morning might affect communication.
An unfamiliar environment might affect movement.
A poor night's sleep might alter how a familiar activity is experienced.
A favourite song could change the tone of an entire afternoon.
When each specialist sees only their own category, the overall experience can disappear.
Bohm's criticism of fragmentation becomes concrete here.
The categories are supposed to help us understand the person.
The person is not supposed to reorganise their existence to satisfy the categories.
An actual conversation, for a change
Some of Bohm's most practically significant later work concerned dialogue.
He distinguished dialogue from the familiar experience of people exchanging arguments while hoping their own position will prevail.
In his approach, participants attempt to notice their assumptions, listen to others and explore how meaning develops through the group.
He used the idea of suspending assumptions.
This does not mean pretending to have no opinions.
It means being able to hold an assumption in view rather than immediately acting as its lawyer.
A friend says something that irritates you.
You notice your reaction.
Ordinarily, you might leap straight into the response, carefully assembling every available piece of evidence demonstrating that your friend must be wrong.
A quite impressive intellectual performance.
Unfortunately, it may produce absolutely no understanding.
Suspending the assumption creates another possibility.
What am I assuming?
Why did I react?
What might the other person mean?
What haven't I understood?
You may ultimately disagree.
You may even be right.
But at least the disagreement has had an opportunity to reveal something.
The point of dialogue isn't compulsory harmony.
It's the possibility of discovering what a conversation contains before reducing it to winners and losers.
Listening is not surrender
There's an important qualification.
Listening does not require abandoning judgement, evidence, rights or boundaries.
If somebody is describing a dangerous action, we may need to intervene.
If a claim is demonstrably false, we don't have to pretend every interpretation is equally credible.
And if a person holds power over others, a conversation about equality doesn't automatically correct the imbalance.
Bohm's method is most useful when participants have enough safety and opportunity to speak, when assumptions can genuinely be questioned, and when the process doesn't become a tool for preventing necessary decisions.
A group can spend so long admiring its shared openness that nothing changes.
Meanwhile, the person whose circumstances prompted the discussion is still waiting.
Dialogue should deepen practical understanding, not replace practical responsibility.
In a Circle of Support, for example, the most important participant may communicate without conventional speech.
A room full of fluent speakers could exchange wonderfully thoughtful perspectives while completely overlooking that person.
That would be a rather spectacular failure of dialogue.
The task isn't simply to make every professional feel heard.
It is to recognise whose life is being discussed and ensure their communication, choices and lived experience have genuine influence.
Bohm helps us examine the process.
The Smiling Monad insists that the person remain central within it.
The encounter with Krishnamurti
Bohm's work on thought and dialogue developed partly through his long relationship with Jiddu Krishnamurti.
They first met in the early 1960s and spent years discussing fear, conditioning, consciousness, the observer and the observed.
Krishnamurti questioned whether human beings could perceive psychological reality without the distortions created by habitual thought and self-centred identification.
Bohm brought the concerns of a theoretical physicist to that conversation.
The recordings can be demanding, fascinating and occasionally frustrating.
Two intelligent people ask a question.
They question the question.
Then they question whether the person doing the questioning has already introduced the division they're trying to understand.
An ordinary chat about the weather it is not.
But their exchange had an important quality.
Neither could simply settle the discussion by claiming possession of the correct answer.
They were investigating what it meant to observe thought while being caught up in it.
There is an obvious temptation to turn this relationship into a claim that quantum physics had finally confirmed ancient spiritual teachings.
That would miss the point.
A physicist's interest in spiritual questions doesn't make those questions experimentally proven.
And a spiritual philosopher's insight into human experience doesn't turn their observations into quantum equations.
The dialogue matters because distinct kinds of enquiry met without automatically becoming identical.
The trick of declaring everything connected
Here is where the comparison with The Smiling Monad gets serious.
Bohm imagined deeper wholeness underlying familiar separateness.
Bohm's account of wholeness challenges fragmented thinking; it does not, by itself, prove a metaphysics of universal consciousness.
Both resist the idea that the world is fundamentally just a heap of unrelated objects.
But Bohm's implicate order is not simply another name for universal consciousness.
His physical work offered ways of thinking about quantum theory.
His philosophical extensions explored mind, meaning, process and wholeness.
The Smiling Monad makes a more specific metaphysical claim about the ultimate source.
That claim remains open to challenge.
Quantum mechanics doesn't establish it.
A hologram doesn't establish it.
A productive dialogue doesn't establish it.
The comparison is valuable not because Bohm supplies a prestigious scientific stamp of approval, but because he shows how difficult it can be to investigate a world while assuming that the divisions we use to describe it are final.
And he offers another question that The Smiling Monad needs to answer.
If reality is one, why do individual experiences remain genuinely different?
How do we recognise difference without treating it as fundamental isolation?
And how do we prevent the language of unity from making other people's interests disappear?
The whole isn't an excuse to ignore the individual
Imagine somebody telling you that because everything is connected, your personal preferences don't really matter.
There's only one reality, they explain, and therefore it would be more spiritually advanced if you stopped making a fuss.
What a convenient philosophy for the person giving the orders.
Any serious account of wholeness has to resist that manoeuvre.
The existence of a larger system doesn't make its individual participants irrelevant.
In fact, many of the most important consequences of systems become visible through what happens to particular lives.
A healthy ecosystem doesn't require every organism to perform the same function.
An orchestra doesn't become more coherent when all the musicians play the same note.
A community isn't strengthened by eliminating disagreement.
Coordination and uniformity are different things.
And connection should not be confused with control.
The Smiling Monad sees individual perspectives as central to the richness of the whole.
That means a person's unfamiliar way of communicating is not automatically something to be corrected.
A difference of opinion may be valuable information.
And a support system should be evaluated partly by whether people have meaningful opportunities to live lives of their choosing.
Wholeness without individuality is a dangerously incomplete picture.
A universe without filing cabinets?
There is a danger in reacting to fragmentation by throwing away every distinction.
Science depends on careful definitions.
Medicine depends on differentiating conditions.
Human rights depend on recognising particular forms of disadvantage and discrimination.
Without categories, we couldn't investigate problems or design effective responses.
The aim is not to stop analysing.
It is to remember that analysis is a tool.
You can take a car apart to understand its engine.
But if your only objective is producing ever more detailed piles of components, the original car will never drive anywhere.
And you probably shouldn't become the head mechanic.
Likewise, you can analyse a relationship in terms of communication, habits, emotion, social context and individual needs.
But the lived relationship is not reducible to a stack of separate reports.
Understanding requires moving between the detail and the wider situation.
Bohm's criticism of fragmentation is strongest when read in that spirit: not as an attack on expertise, but as a warning against mistaking a useful partial picture for the whole of reality.
The unfinished work of seeing
David Bohm died in London in 1992.
His legacy remains unusually varied.
Bohmian mechanics continues to be studied as a serious approach to quantum foundations.
The Aharonov–Bohm effect belongs to established physics.
The implicate order remains a provocative but not conclusively verified proposal about deeper reality.
His work on dialogue continues to interest educators, organisations and people trying to think together without turning every disagreement into a competitive sport.
None of those contributions needs to be exaggerated to become impressive.
Perhaps the most useful thing about Bohm is that he was willing to question the assumptions supporting even successful explanations.
He didn't reject the achievements of science.
He asked whether there might be more to understand.
And he recognised that thought itself could become part of the difficulty when we mistake the categories it creates for the complete structure of the world.
The Smiling Monad can take that challenge seriously without borrowing certainty that Bohm did not possess.
If we propose that existence is one unfolding consciousness, we should remain interested in evidence, alternative explanations and perspectives that don't fit neatly into our picture.
A philosophy of connection should be especially willing to listen.
Because the person who disagrees with us is also part of the reality we're trying to understand.
And sometimes the most interesting thing in the room is not the theory, the presentation or the terribly impressive diagram on the wall.
It's the person nobody has properly heard yet.
We can continue dividing the universe into useful little boxes.
Just remember to open them occasionally.
The music is happening between the instruments.
The conversation is happening between the speakers.
And reality, whatever its ultimate nature, has never been particularly interested in following our filing system.
Ben Grey · 14 November 2026
