Hildegard of Bingen — The Devil Couldn't Sing
The Devil had a problem.
He couldn't sing.
Not badly. Not out of tune. Not the sort of singing that clears a room at karaoke night.
He didn't have a musical part at all.
In Ordo Virtutum, a twelfth-century drama by Hildegard of Bingen, the Soul sings. The Virtues sing. Their voices rise and unfold through long, elaborate melodies.
Then the Devil appears and has to speak.
Everyone else gets the music. The villain gets the dialogue.
It's a marvellous theatrical decision.
No digital effects. No smoke machine. No enormous mechanical dragon rolling onto the stage.
Just the absence of something that everybody else possesses.
Hildegard's drama concerns a soul drawn away from virtue and eventually welcomed back. The Devil's inability to participate in the music helps distinguish his role within the story.
It also tells us something about its author.
For Hildegard, music wasn't entertainment added after the serious business of religion. It belonged to how she understood life itself: bodies, voices, community, beauty and the relationship between creation and its divine source.
And near the end of her life, when church authorities prohibited her community from singing, she fought back.
A woman who had spent decades finding a voice for the cosmos was told to be quiet.
That is a story worth listening to.
A life that refused to stay in one category
Hildegard was born in 1098 in the Rhineland, in what is now Germany, into a family of some means.
As a child, she entered the care of a religious community associated with the Benedictine monastery at Disibodenberg. The documentary chronology of her earliest years is complicated, but by 1112 she was formally part of the women's enclosure there.
Her mentor was Jutta of Sponheim, whose death in 1136 led to Hildegard's election as leader of the growing community.
In her early forties, Hildegard began the work that would make her extraordinary.
She recorded visionary experiences that became the foundation of Scivias, a vast theological and illustrated account of creation, salvation, humanity and divine order.
Later came more visionary books, letters, sermons, music, writings on nature and healing, and an invented language with its own vocabulary.
She corresponded with prominent religious and political figures.
She travelled to preach publicly.
She founded a monastery at Rupertsberg and established another at Eibingen.
She managed people, buildings, disputes and the many practical difficulties involved in sustaining a community.
If somebody tried to fit her into a modern professional directory, the application would probably crash.
Composer? Yes.
Writer? Yes.
Theologian? Yes.
Natural-history observer? Certainly.
Abbess, administrator, correspondent, visionary, playwright?
All of the above.
But describing Hildegard as a woman who could do absolutely everything carries its own risk.
It turns her into a medieval superhero instead of a historical person.
She lived within the religious and social structures of her time. Her authority depended partly on them. She had collaborators and scribes. She disagreed with people, suffered illness, loved particular companions and faced consequences for decisions she made.
The extraordinary part isn't that she floated above ordinary life.
It's how much she did while being completely immersed in it.
The visions and the person who had them
Hildegard said she experienced extraordinary perceptions from childhood, but it was around 1141 that she understood herself to have received a command to record them.
Her descriptions refer to light, powerful images and a form of insight that she did not simply equate with dreams or losing ordinary awareness.
The resulting Scivias contains elaborate visions of creation, the structure of the universe, human beings and Christian salvation.
Imagine opening a medieval manuscript and encountering concentric cosmic circles, blazing figures, strange beasts, symbolic landscapes and human bodies placed within vast arrangements of stars and light.
The pictures don't look like the modest visual aids somebody added to make a difficult textbook less boring.
They look as though the illustrator was given access to an entirely different design department.
But we should ask what the images were for.
They were not modern astronomical diagrams. Their purpose was theological and symbolic.
Hildegard understood the visions within a Christian account of God, creation, the Church and the struggle between virtue and sin.
They expressed meaning through forms that ordinary descriptive prose could not easily contain.
And the manuscripts were the products of real people and workshops. The relationship between Hildegard's visions, her direction and the artists' contributions remains a subject of scholarship.
There's a modern habit of retrospectively diagnosing historical figures.
Hildegard's visions have sometimes been explained as migraine aura, among other neurological possibilities.
That explanation may sound appealing because some descriptions resemble visual phenomena associated with migraine.
But resemblance isn't a diagnosis.
We can't examine her neurological state with the methods we would use today, and her accounts were shaped by the theological language and artistic practices of her world.
Her experiences were real experiences for her.
What caused them, and what ultimate reality they might reveal, are different questions.
A neuroscientific hypothesis does not automatically disprove the personal or religious significance someone finds in an experience.
Equally, the strength of that significance does not establish that the images provide a scientific description of the universe.
We can take both the woman and the questions seriously without pretending the evidence is more complete than it is.
She gave the universe a voice
Hildegard's music is the reason I would most like to be able to spend an afternoon in her community.
Her surviving compositions include seventy-seven liturgical chants associated with the Symphonia, alongside the extended sung drama Ordo Virtutum.
The music is generally monophonic: a single melodic line, rather than the layered harmonies familiar from much later Western music.
But that single line can travel.
It rises, stretches, returns and moves through long chains of notes attached to a syllable.
Musicians call that kind of ornamentation melisma.
You don't need to remember the word to notice the effect.
A syllable that might take a second in ordinary speech becomes an experience extended through breath and melody.
The singers aren't simply delivering information.
They are giving language physical movement.
The music also belongs to a particular monastic culture. These were sacred texts composed for religious life, not general-purpose relaxation tracks designed for a modern mindfulness playlist.
And the surviving medieval notation doesn't preserve every performance detail. We can study the melodic lines, manuscripts and historical setting without claiming to know precisely how a performance sounded in Hildegard's own room.
That uncertainty matters.
It's possible to appreciate something without pretending we've reconstructed it perfectly.
What survives is more than enough to be interesting.
A woman whose institutional world restricted many kinds of authority was composing music that demanded unusual expressive range.
She wasn't merely explaining what harmony meant.
She was making people sing.
The Soul makes a decision
Return to Ordo Virtutum.
The story is not complicated in outline.
A human soul encounters the Virtues, who represent qualities such as Humility and Charity.
The Devil tempts the soul away.
The soul experiences the consequences and eventually returns.
The Virtues receive and restore her.
Within its Benedictine setting, the drama concerns salvation, community and the moral life.
But the choice to perform the story changes how the audience encounters it.
The Soul isn't an abstract point in an argument.
She has a voice.
The Virtues aren't merely words in a theological handbook.
They respond to her, sing to her and draw her into a community.
The Devil is present but deprived of the same musical mode of expression.
This wasn't a modern improvisational drama about choosing one's personal lifestyle. Its theological meanings were firmly rooted in the world of Hildegard's convent.
Yet the structure raises a fascinating question about how communities work.
What does it mean to have a voice within a shared experience?
And what changes when someone is no longer able to participate in the same way?
The answers are not simply contained in the musical notation.
But the drama makes the questions felt.
That's what art can do that an explanation alone sometimes can't.
Then they banned the music
In Hildegard's final years, a dispute arose over a man buried in the cemetery at Rupertsberg.
Church authorities at Mainz maintained that he had died excommunicated and that his body should be removed from consecrated ground.
Hildegard insisted that he had been reconciled with the Church before his death.
She refused the demand to disinter him.
The authorities imposed an interdict on her community.
Among its consequences, the nuns were forbidden from singing their usual liturgical offices.
Think about the significance.
This wasn't a community whose members happened to enjoy singing after work.
Their singing was part of the structure of their day, their religious identity and their shared way of life.
And Hildegard had developed an extraordinary theology around the human voice.
So, faced with an order to remain silent, she wrote to the authorities.
Her letter wasn't a cheerful customer-service enquiry.
She defended the community's position and argued for the spiritual importance of musical praise.
It is possible to disagree with her theology and still appreciate the force of the complaint.
The penalty didn't merely suspend an optional cultural activity.
It struck at a central means through which the community understood and expressed its life.
The dispute was eventually resolved, and the interdict was lifted in 1179, not long before Hildegard's death.
We shouldn't pretend that every aspect of the case is uncomplicated. It involved canon law, burial rights, competing claims about the deceased man's status and the authority of church officials.
But the human stakes are clear enough.
A woman who gave music such profound meaning was confronted with an institution that could remove it by decree.
If you're going to write an opera in which the Devil has no singing part, it's a particularly cruel twist to have your own singers silenced.
What was actually taken away?
The temptation is to turn the interdict into a simple story about oppressive authority crushing creative expression.
There's truth in the conflict, but the larger situation is more interesting.
Hildegard did not reject religious institutions in principle.
She was a powerful participant in one.
Her monastery required rules, administration, leadership and shared obligations.
She also exercised authority herself.
The conflict wasn't between a completely free individual and the very idea of structure.
It was over how authority should be exercised, which obligations mattered and what a punishment did to the life of a community.
That distinction travels well beyond the twelfth century.
Rules can be necessary.
They can protect people, distribute responsibilities and make cooperation possible.
But a rule can also become disconnected from the purpose it was supposed to serve.
When that happens, the procedure survives while the experience it was meant to support disappears.
The community still exists.
The schedule still exists.
The authority remains perfectly intact.
But the voices have gone.
That's a much more disturbing possibility than somebody simply having their favourite activity cancelled.
It asks whether institutions understand what their rules actually remove from people's lives.
The green word
Hildegard had another image she returned to repeatedly: viriditas.
The Latin word is commonly translated as greenness, but in her writing it carries a wider theological sense of vitality, fecundity and the living power associated with God's creation.
Imagine a landscape after drought.
For months the ground has been hard, the grass brittle and the leaves faded.
Then the rain arrives.
Green shoots appear.
The landscape hasn't become an entirely different universe.
Its capacity for life has become visible again.
Hildegard used greenness in richly symbolic ways to describe the life-giving activity of divine power, moral flourishing and the relation between spiritual and material existence.
She saw a profound correspondence between the living world and the religious meaning she found within it.
That doesn't make her a twenty-first-century environmental scientist.
She wasn't measuring biodiversity loss or developing climate models.
And viriditas wasn't a medieval branding term for organic vegetable juice.
Its meanings grew from biblical interpretation, Christian theology and earlier writing, adapted through her own visionary style.
But the image has lasting force.
Life isn't simply a collection of objects.
It involves conditions through which things grow, develop and recover.
A plant can possess all the genetic possibilities required for growth and still fail in depleted soil.
A child can have extraordinary curiosity and lose confidence in an environment where every question is treated as a nuisance.
A person can possess skills, preferences and intentions but have few opportunities to exercise them.
The differences between plants and people are obviously important.
Still, the comparison directs attention toward the conditions that allow life to flourish.
That's a more useful question than simply demanding that everybody look cheerful.
Nature is not a medicine cupboard with unlimited credentials
Hildegard also wrote, or contributed materials later compiled, on animals, plants, stones, bodily conditions and remedies.
The works now known as Physica and Causae et Curae have complicated manuscript histories. Scholars have shown that their surviving forms involve later compilation and transmission, not simply two pristine notebooks written in Hildegard's own hand.
They are important evidence of medieval thinking about nature and healing.
They bring together inherited medical ideas, observations, religious meanings and theories about the relationship between human bodies and the surrounding world.
This is fascinating history.
It is not a reason to follow every remedy.
Medieval medical theories included ideas that modern scientific investigation has revised or rejected. Some historical substances and practices could be unsafe.
The modern market for 'Hildegard medicine' has sometimes attached her name to dietary systems, products and treatments that cannot be straightforwardly established from the medieval texts.
So we should resist the rather dangerous assumption that an old remedy is effective because it is old.
A historical description of a medicinal plant may provide a research question.
It doesn't establish dosage, effectiveness or safety.
If somebody needs medical treatment, the relevant standard is contemporary evidence and competent clinical care—not the promise that a twelfth-century abbess has already solved everything.
Hildegard was curious about the natural world.
A response worthy of that curiosity is to investigate carefully, not to suspend investigation in her honour.
The body was never just an inconvenience
There is, however, something useful in her effort to consider the body within a larger account of living.
She didn't always approach physical existence as an obstacle to spiritual life.
In her theology, embodiment had meaning.
Human beings were living creatures whose physical and spiritual dimensions belonged within God's creation.
Her writing connected food, environment, feeling, work and health, although its explanatory framework differs substantially from contemporary medicine.
The idea that experience is shaped by more than an isolated mental decision is hardly controversial.
Our bodies matter.
Sleep matters.
Pain matters.
Movement, nourishment, access to environments and relationships can affect how we experience a day.
But this doesn't mean all bodily conditions have a simple emotional or spiritual cause.
A sick person hasn't failed to maintain the right frequency.
Someone experiencing disability doesn't need to be made spiritually greener.
And a person who is unhappy isn't evidence of a defective inner universe.
We can recognise relationships among the dimensions of life without making the individual responsible for every circumstance affecting them.
A philosophy of flourishing ought to increase understanding and support.
Not find new, beautifully worded reasons to blame people for struggling.
A woman with allies, opponents and an actual institution to run
It is tempting to portray Hildegard as a solitary woman battling an entirely hostile male world.
She certainly faced gendered limitations within medieval church culture.
Her authority as a visionary woman required particular forms of recognition and legitimation.
But she also gained influential supporters, including religious leaders who encouraged or endorsed her work.
She had scribes, correspondents and collaborators.
The monk Volmar assisted in recording and preparing texts.
The nun Richardis von Stade played an important role in her early writing and was a beloved companion.
When Richardis left to become abbess at another monastery, Hildegard experienced a painful loss.
The surviving correspondence reminds us that the writer of vast cosmic visions was also capable of grief, attachment and the complicated emotions of friendship.
The institution mattered too.
Hildegard sought greater independence for her community when she moved the women from Disibodenberg to Rupertsberg.
She faced resistance to that decision and had to negotiate questions of property, leadership and religious authority.
These were not abstract exercises.
They affected where women lived, how they organised their religious lives and who controlled the resources sustaining them.
Her creativity didn't float above the material world.
It depended on people, places, manuscripts, time and a community capable of preserving the work.
There is a practical lesson in that without needing to turn it into a sermon.
If we want creativity to flourish, admiration alone doesn't provide the conditions.
Somebody still needs to make room for it.
Not quite a modern feminist—or an environmental activist
Hildegard was a remarkable woman exercising extraordinary intellectual authority within the twelfth-century Church.
That makes her important in the history of women's writing and music.
But it doesn't follow that she held modern views about gender equality or social freedom.
She remained committed to her Christian theology, monastic hierarchy and many of the assumptions of her age.
She criticised religious opponents and participated in disputes that reflected the exclusions and hostilities of medieval society.
We should also be careful with the claim that she was an early environmentalist.
Her imagery of nature can resonate strongly with contemporary ecological concerns.
But she was not working with present-day scientific knowledge or the politics of modern environmental movements.
These differences don't diminish her achievements.
They make them more specific.
A person doesn't have to agree with everything we believe to contribute something valuable to our understanding.
And an essay about a historical figure becomes more interesting when we discover an actual person instead of manufacturing a convenient ally.
Hildegard's music, writings and leadership deserve their own place in history.
They don't need to be turned into a modern campaign poster.
When a melody belongs to everyone in the room
Consider something ordinary.
A group of people are gathered around a familiar song.
One sings confidently.
Another hums.
Someone taps along.
Somebody else sits quietly, listening.
One person might communicate through movement rather than words.
The music is shared, but the experiences are not identical.
And there is no need for everyone to contribute in precisely the same way.
This is where Hildegard's work offers a particularly interesting conversation with The Smiling Monad.
Music can create a shared setting without requiring uniform participation.
Rhythm, melody, expectation and attention may help people find ways of being together.
But we should not assume music is always soothing or welcome.
A piece that delights one person can overwhelm another.
Silence can be comforting, distressing, peaceful or merely inconvenient, depending on the circumstances and the person.
Nor does a musical response automatically reveal what somebody wants or feels.
Participation matters because it is chosen and experienced, not simply because others think the result looks harmonious.
The Smiling Monad's emphasis on individual rhythms is not an instruction that everyone must join the same song.
It is a reminder to make room for different ways of participating.
Sometimes the best contribution to a musical moment is to sing.
Sometimes it's to listen.
And sometimes it's to turn the volume down because the person beside you has had enough.
What science can tell us about music
Music is a legitimate subject of neuroscience and psychological research.
Researchers investigate auditory processing, memory, emotion, motor coordination, social engagement and how musical interventions may affect particular clinical outcomes.
There is evidence for benefits in some contexts, with important differences between studies, populations, intervention types and outcomes.
That is quite different from claiming every musical frequency has a universal therapeutic effect or that a particular chant automatically restores the body's ideal vibration.
The physics of sound is real.
Sound has measurable properties.
The experience of sound depends on hearing, nervous systems, learning, environment, preferences and context.
But phrases about 'healing frequencies' can easily become misleading when they jump from measurable sound waves to untested claims about consciousness or illness.
Hildegard's belief in music's spiritual significance belongs to her theology.
The Smiling Monad's interpretation of shared experience belongs to its philosophy.
Modern music research belongs to empirical investigation.
There is room for a conversation among all three.
None needs to impersonate the others.
Hildegard gives us something especially valuable: an example of someone who understood musical expression as important enough to defend publicly.
We don't need to pretend she was performing controlled clinical trials to recognise the importance of that decision.
A different kind of interconnectedness
Some of Hildegard's cosmic illustrations place human beings within elaborate systems of light, elements, celestial forms and living forces.
A modern viewer might be tempted to announce that she had discovered quantum fields, universal consciousness and the structure of the multiverse.
She hadn't.
Her universe was shaped by medieval Christian theology, classical natural philosophy and visionary symbolism.
The comparison matters because Hildegard's theological world and this philosophy describe the source differently, even as both take sound, beauty and human experience seriously.
There is a meaningful resemblance in the refusal to treat the human individual as an entirely self-sufficient unit outside a larger reality.
There is also a major difference in what that larger reality is understood to be.
For Hildegard it was creation dependent on the Christian God, illuminated through scripture and revelation.
The Smiling Monad frames the ultimate source as consciousness rather than a specifically Christian theological account.
The resemblance is a place to begin questioning, not a reason to erase her beliefs.
And perhaps the most rewarding comparison isn't cosmic architecture at all.
It's the attention she gave to expression.
A living being isn't merely something to classify.
A voice isn't merely a container for information.
Creative activity can reveal possibilities that formal descriptions miss.
That's especially worth considering in education, communication and support, where people can be so thoroughly documented that nobody notices what they're trying to do.
She wasn't trying to make everybody smile
Hildegard's vision of the good life wasn't a modern invitation to pursue whichever activities made an individual happy.
She believed in sin, virtue, divine judgement, obedience and the demanding spiritual responsibilities of her religious tradition.
The drama of the Soul and the Virtues was not a celebration of unrestricted choice.
It had a theological direction.
We shouldn't hide that because it complicates the comparison.
The Smiling Monad's invitation to live well and contribute to others' happiness is different.
It emphasises individuality, relationships and the freedom to pursue meaningful experiences while respecting others.
But the difference creates a question worth keeping.
Can a shared philosophy, community or institution create belonging without making every participant identical?
Hildegard's music gives us an unusually vivid image.
A community sings through one melodic tradition.
Yet distinct voices, texts, performances and relationships make that shared life possible.
The music belongs to a tradition with rules.
The women who sing it are not merely the rules.
And when the singing is taken away, something essential about their participation is lost.
The world is still making music
Hildegard died on 17 September 1179.
In 2012, Pope Benedict XVI formally extended her recognition as a saint to the universal Catholic Church and declared her a Doctor of the Church.
Her writings continue to be studied.
Her music is recorded and performed.
The manuscripts that preserve her work provide evidence not just of a remarkable author but of the communities that copied, illustrated and transmitted it.
This is an extraordinary afterlife for someone who lived nearly nine hundred years ago.
And perhaps the most interesting part is not simply that she was ahead of her time.
That phrase can make history sound like a competition in which the winner is whoever most closely resembles us.
Hildegard was profoundly of her time.
She understood existence through a world of Christian symbols, liturgy, theological argument and monastic life.
From within that world, she created things we can still encounter.
Songs.
Images.
Questions.
Arguments.
A drama in which the Devil cannot sing.
She reminds us that creativity is not merely the production of something new.
It can be a way of giving form to an experience that other people are then able to encounter.
And that encounter can survive the creator.
Centuries later, somebody who has never heard of Disibodenberg can listen to one of her melodies and find it moving.
Not because the listener necessarily shares her theology.
Not because a medieval chant scientifically proves the existence of universal consciousness.
But because a person from another time created something that still makes an experience possible.
The Smiling Monad doesn't need to claim Hildegard as one of its own to appreciate that.
Her work stands on its own.
And the question it leaves us with is surprisingly immediate.
What allows the people around us to express themselves fully?
What helps them participate?
What unnecessary restrictions are silencing something that matters to them?
We could spend the afternoon debating what it means for the universe to have a voice.
We could also make sure the people living in it get to use theirs.
Hildegard managed to do both.
Not a bad effort for someone who lived before electricity, recording equipment or the invention of the microphone.
And she had the good sense to give the Devil a speaking part.
Every production needs someone who doesn't know when to stop talking.
Ben Grey · 14 November 2026
Further reading
- Hildegard of Bingen, Scivias (composed c. 1141–1151).
• Hildegard of Bingen, Symphonia armonie celestium revelationum (collection of chants).
• Hildegard of Bingen, Ordo Virtutum (c. 1151–1152).
• Hildegard of Bingen, Liber divinorum operum (Book of Divine Works).
• Jennifer Bain, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Hildegard of Bingen (Cambridge University Press, 2021): https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-companion-to-hildegard-of-bingen/60C953CC0C2B6E6CC80DB465F9D19E6B
• Michael Embach, 'The Life of Hildegard of Bingen,' in The Cambridge Companion to Hildegard of Bingen: https://assets.cambridge.org/97811084/71350/excerpt/9781108471350_excerpt.pdf
• International Society of Hildegard von Bingen Studies, music and manuscript resources: https://www.hildegard-society.org/p/music.html
• British Library, manuscript Add MS 15102, including Ordo Virtutum: https://searcharchives.bl.uk/catalog/032-002086795
• Faith Wallis, 'Hildegard of Bingen: Illness and Healing,' The Cambridge Companion to Hildegard of Bingen (2021): https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-companion-to-hildegard-of-bingen/hildegard-of-bingen-illness-and-healing/E3F4632CA118ED617C3B25B7A0C7AB7D
• Peter V. Loewen, 'From the Roots to the Branches: Greenness in the Preaching of Hildegard of Bingen and the Patriarchs,' The Cambridge Companion to Hildegard of Bingen (2021): https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-companion-to-hildegard-of-bingen/from-the-roots-to-the-branches-greenness-in-the-preaching-of-hildegard-of-bingen-and-the-patriarchs/7D851A9A05E2B1AA3395FAADC31D65E7
• Michael O'Connor, 'Music, Breath, and Spirit,' Open Book Publishers (2024): https://books.openbookpublishers.com/10.11647/obp.0403.03.pdf
• Joseph L. Baird, ed., The Personal Correspondence of Hildegard of Bingen, section on Richardis von Stade (Oxford University Press, 2006): https://academic.oup.com/book/36034/chapter-abstract/313098243
• Pope Benedict XVI, apostolic letter proclaiming Hildegard a Doctor of the Church (7 October 2012): https://www.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/en/apost_letters/documents/hf_ben-xvi_apl_20121007_ildegarda-bingen.html
