Jane Goodall — The Animals Were Never the Problem
Imagine spending years insisting that humans are the only creatures clever enough to make tools.
We've built magnificent cities, mapped distant galaxies and developed machines capable of discussing the meaning of existence while occasionally giving us completely incorrect directions to the supermarket.
Clearly we're special.
Then a young woman sits quietly in a Tanzanian forest and watches a chimpanzee modify a piece of vegetation to collect termites.
That must have been an awkward day for anyone whose definition of humanity depended on having exclusive rights to the toolbox.
Jane Goodall hadn't gone to Gombe to humiliate philosophers.
She wanted to understand chimpanzees.
What she discovered was far more unsettling than one clever animal with a twig: the boundary humanity had drawn between itself and the rest of life wasn't nearly as tidy as we'd imagined.
And the more carefully she looked, the more interesting the neighbours became.
The woman who watched before explaining
In July 1960, twenty-six-year-old Jane Goodall travelled to Gombe, on the shores of Lake Tanganyika in what is now Tanzania, to begin observing wild chimpanzees.
She had no conventional university science degree. The palaeoanthropologist Louis Leakey had encouraged her to pursue the work, and her mother accompanied her in the early stages.
The chimpanzees were not immediately impressed by the new arrival.
They avoided her.
Which, when you think about it, is a perfectly reasonable response to an unfamiliar human turning up in your neighbourhood with binoculars and taking extensive notes about your family.
Goodall's earliest achievement was not a spectacular discovery. It was the patience required to make discoveries possible.
She watched, waited and gradually learned to recognise individuals and their relationships.
It sounds simple until you consider how much of modern life is built around exactly the opposite approach.
We encounter someone unfamiliar, assign them a category and begin explaining what the category means.
Sometimes the explanation arrives before the person has even opened their mouth.
Goodall entered the forest with questions, not with a complete account of who its inhabitants were supposed to be.
Her research would eventually become the foundation of one of the longest-running wild chimpanzee studies in the world, continued by Tanzanian field researchers and international collaborators long after her first observations.
That continuation matters. The story isn't about a solitary genius who single-handedly discovered Africa's wildlife. It is about sustained inquiry, many contributors and the value of watching closely over generations.
David Greybeard and the twig that caused trouble
One chimpanzee, whom Goodall named David Greybeard, became central to her early observations.
She saw him use plant material to extract termites. More importantly, she observed chimpanzees altering vegetation to create better tools for the task.
Tool use and tool modification were not practices that prevailing accounts of human exceptionalism had expected to find in wild chimpanzees.
Leakey responded with a memorable challenge to the old definition of humans as uniquely tool-making animals.
The popular story is sometimes overstated. Goodall did not single-handedly prove that humans and chimpanzees are identical, nor did she discover that all other animals are incapable of invention.
The significance was more precise.
A supposedly clear distinction needed reconsideration because observation had contradicted it.
Science progressed by revising its description of the world.
That's what science is supposed to do.
It's considerably more useful than defending a definition until the evidence becomes sufficiently embarrassed to go away.
The twig itself was ordinary.
The changed understanding was extraordinary.
What else had we overlooked because we were too confident about which abilities belonged exclusively to us?
Flo is not Number Six
Goodall also did something that annoyed some of her academic contemporaries.
She gave the chimpanzees names.
David Greybeard. Flo. Fifi. Flint.
At Cambridge, where she later completed a doctorate, she faced criticism for describing animals in terms of personalities and emotions.
The worry wasn't entirely foolish. Scientific observation can be distorted when researchers project human feelings and motives onto animals.
A chimpanzee showing its teeth isn't necessarily sharing a cheerful human smile.
We cannot simply invent a story about what another creature is thinking because it fits our favourite theory.
But there is an opposite error.
We can become so frightened of anthropomorphism—incorrectly attributing human characteristics to animals—that we refuse to recognise evidence of individual differences, relationships or emotional responses at all.
Imagine meeting a family and insisting on referring to everyone as Subject A, B and C because names might make you overly sympathetic.
You could still collect data.
You might also miss something rather important about the family.
Goodall's work helped move animal behaviour research toward a more detailed understanding of individual histories and social relationships.
Flo, a prominent mother at Gombe, wasn't interchangeable with every other female chimpanzee.
Her offspring developed within the particular relationships of their family group.
Young animals learned, played, competed and depended on others.
Individuality was not an invention of the observer. It was something to investigate.
Giving an animal a name doesn't establish its inner experience.
But refusing to recognise a distinct individual doesn't make an observation more accurate.
Sometimes it simply makes the observer less curious.
A society, not a collection of furry specimens
The chimpanzees at Gombe weren't living as isolated biological machines.
They groomed one another, formed alliances, cared for young, competed for rank, shared some food and participated in complicated social relationships.
Some interactions were affectionate.
Others were tense.
Relationships changed with age, experience and circumstance.
We know from decades of primatology that social learning also helps shape behaviours across chimpanzee populations. Different communities show different patterns of tool use and other practices.
That doesn't make chimpanzee culture identical to human culture.
It does mean that an account of animal behaviour based entirely on fixed instinct is incomplete.
A young chimpanzee develops within a particular social world.
What it encounters matters.
What others do matters.
What it learns to attend to matters.
This should sound familiar to anyone who has ever watched a human child learning how the world works.
But similarity is not equivalence.
Our close evolutionary relationship with chimpanzees is real. So are differences in language, cultural accumulation, institutions and other capacities.
Good science neither erases the differences nor exaggerates them to preserve our vanity.
It investigates what is actually there.
The dark discovery
And here is where a sentimental version of Jane Goodall's story becomes inadequate.
Chimpanzees were not simply peaceful forest philosophers teaching humanity to be kind.
In the 1970s, researchers at Gombe documented the violent conflict commonly called the Four-Year War, following a split between chimpanzee communities.
Individuals were attacked and killed.
Goodall also documented infanticide and cannibalism.
The observations were disturbing, not least because the researchers had already witnessed tenderness and close family bonds among the same species.
This was no children's television programme in which every animal has a lovely personality and the only villain is an unusually grumpy badger.
It was a complicated living society containing cooperation and violence.
There has also been serious scientific debate about the circumstances in which some of the observations occurred.
At Gombe, researchers sometimes supplied bananas to habituate chimpanzees and facilitate study. Research published in the 1970s documented that the method and availability of provisioning could affect aggregation and aggression.
Later scholars have debated how habitat pressures, research conditions and other factors should figure in accounts of chimpanzee violence.
Those qualifications matter.
We should not convert any one community's history into proof that warfare is inevitable for every chimpanzee—or that human warfare is merely an unavoidable genetic destiny.
Nor should we ignore documented violence because it spoils a comforting picture of nature.
The same creature can engage in behaviours we find recognisably affectionate and others we find horrifying.
A close evolutionary relationship with humans does not mean chimpanzees are morally responsible in the same way humans are.
The science tells us about behaviour and possible evolutionary patterns.
It does not excuse human cruelty.
And perhaps the larger lesson is that reality rarely cooperates with our desire to divide living beings into completely good and completely bad categories.
Do animals have an inner life?
Here we reach one of the biggest questions.
What does it feel like to be a chimpanzee?
We can study perception, memory, decision-making, learning and social behaviour.
We can examine brains, nervous systems and evolutionary relationships.
We can investigate signs consistent with emotion, preference and awareness.
But we cannot simply enter another animal's subjective experience and read it like an open book.
This is a version of the problem philosophers face when discussing consciousness in general.
I can observe your behaviour, listen to your words and learn about your nervous system.
Yet your experience is still yours, not mine.
The difficulty becomes greater when communication differs so dramatically.
A chimpanzee does not need to deliver a speech about its identity for its welfare to matter.
But the absence of a shared language also creates obligations for careful interpretation.
We should neither assume that animals experience everything exactly as we do nor pretend that only human-style communication could indicate meaningful experience.
And chimpanzees are not the only relevant animals.
Research on corvids, parrots, cetaceans, elephants, cephalopods and many others continues to complicate the old belief that intelligence is arranged in a single tidy hierarchy with humanity sitting comfortably at the top.
Different ecological problems can produce very different capacities.
An octopus doesn't need to behave like a chimpanzee to be fascinating.
A bird doesn't need human hands to solve a problem.
We've been a little too eager to define intelligence by asking how well other beings perform at activities humans happen to enjoy.
That is rather like declaring fish intellectually disappointing because they refuse to climb trees.
What The Smiling Monad can and cannot claim
Goodall's work makes connection something to observe before it becomes something to theorise about: animals, habitats and the people studying them continually affect one another.
Within that philosophy, humans are not the only possible participants in conscious existence.
Other animals, unfamiliar intelligences and forms of life beyond our present understanding would belong within the same ultimate reality.
This provides a reason to approach unfamiliar experience with humility and curiosity.
But Goodall's research does not demonstrate the metaphysical claim that all minds share one universal source.
Her observations support conclusions about chimpanzee cognition, relationships, behaviour and evolutionary continuity.
The Smiling Monad offers a philosophical interpretation of what interconnected experience might mean beyond those findings.
These are different kinds of claims.
Pretending they're identical would weaken both.
The more interesting question is what follows when we stop treating our own perspective as the unquestionable standard against which every other life must be measured.
What are we failing to notice?
What behaviours have we dismissed?
How much of another creature's life becomes visible only after we've learned to observe on its terms?
Goodall's patience provides an answer in method, even if not a final answer in metaphysics.
Watch carefully.
Remain willing to learn.
And resist the temptation to mistake confidence for understanding.
Connection doesn't mean innocence
There is a trap in talking about universal connection.
It's tempting to imagine that recognising interconnection will automatically produce harmony.
Wouldn't that be lovely?
One philosophical insight, and suddenly all the creatures of Earth begin cooperating like an unusually well-run neighbourhood barbecue.
Unfortunately, ecosystems contain predation, competition, disease, parasitism and death, alongside remarkable cooperation.
Chimpanzee societies contain affection and aggression.
Human societies contain extraordinary kindness and extraordinary cruelty.
Connectedness isn't evidence that every interaction is benevolent.
It is a description of relationships and dependence, not a moral guarantee.
The Smiling Monad's ethical challenge is therefore not to pretend that harm doesn't happen.
It's to consider how creatures capable of reflection might respond to the consequences of their actions.
Humans can examine institutions, recognise suffering, alter behaviour and deliberately protect vulnerable lives.
We don't always do these things.
But we can.
That capacity brings responsibility.
Not because we're separate from nature and appointed to supervise it from above.
Because we are powerful participants within it, capable of changing the conditions under which many other beings live.
And we've become remarkably efficient at doing so.
The forest doesn't survive on admiration alone
Goodall's career changed direction as she confronted the threats facing chimpanzees and their habitats.
It's one thing to observe an extraordinary animal.
It's another to discover that the conditions supporting its existence are disappearing.
Deforestation, habitat fragmentation, disease, illegal wildlife trade and economic pressures pose serious challenges to chimpanzee conservation.
One tempting response is to announce that humans should simply leave nature alone.
That sounds compelling until we remember that people also live around protected areas.
Families need food, income, healthcare, land and opportunities for their children.
Conservation policies that disregard those needs can create injustice, resentment and practical failure.
Goodall increasingly emphasised that the wellbeing of neighbouring communities and the protection of habitats had to be considered together.
In 1994, the Jane Goodall Institute began the Tacare community-led conservation approach around Gombe, working with Tanzanian communities and local expertise.
The work has evolved over time, and its successes and difficulties deserve continuing scrutiny rather than celebratory slogans.
But the basic insight is powerful.
You cannot protect a forest sustainably by pretending the people living beside it are irrelevant.
And you cannot protect people's long-term wellbeing by destroying the ecological systems on which they depend.
This is interconnection made practical.
Not a cosmic diagram.
A relationship between livelihoods, land, decisions and living beings.
Who gets to decide?
There is another lesson here, and it belongs as much to the local communities and Tanzanian researchers as to Goodall herself.
The popular story of science sometimes presents a Western explorer arriving in a distant country and bringing knowledge back to the world.
That story can obscure the expertise of people who know the landscape, collect the data, work on the ground and continue the project across generations.
Gombe's long research history depends on Tanzanian field staff and researchers, not only on its famous founder.
Community-led conservation, properly understood, also requires more than asking residents to approve decisions already made elsewhere.
People need meaningful authority, participation and benefits.
This matters because the language of connection can become hollow when power remains concentrated.
An outside organisation can talk beautifully about community while retaining control over every significant decision.
That isn't a partnership.
It's a presentation.
Goodall's later conservation efforts offer a valuable direction: listen to the people whose lives are directly affected, work with local knowledge and recognise that effective action may depend on shared decision-making.
The principle extends well beyond wildlife protection.
Every system intended to support someone should ask whether that person and their community can genuinely participate in shaping it.
Young people and the dangerous possibility of hope
In 1991, twelve young people in Tanzania met with Goodall to discuss problems that worried them.
Their conversations helped begin Roots & Shoots, a youth-led programme that grew into an international network of community, animal-welfare and environmental projects.
There's something wonderfully sensible about this approach.
Children and young people are often told that they are the future.
Then they're asked to sit quietly while adults make all the decisions about what that future will look like.
Roots & Shoots takes a more interesting position.
Young people can participate now.
They can identify problems, develop projects, learn through action and contribute to their communities.
A group might restore habitat, reduce waste, support animal welfare or improve a local environment.
These aren't necessarily activities requiring enormous budgets or an international conference with twelve keynote speakers explaining the importance of local participation to an audience that wasn't invited to participate.
They can begin with a question.
What do you notice?
What matters to you?
What could we do together?
Goodall's work in this area connects particularly strongly with the educational possibilities explored by The Smiling Monad.
Learning needn't be confined to reproducing information someone else has selected.
It can involve discovering the world, developing relationships, making decisions and experiencing the consequences of meaningful action.
The child isn't merely preparing to participate in reality one day.
The child is already part of it.
Hope isn't the same as optimism
Goodall became closely associated with hope.
But there is a distinction between hope and pretending everything will be fine.
Optimism can sometimes be a prediction about the future.
Hope can be a reason to act without certainty that the outcome will be favourable.
The difference matters during an ecological crisis.
A person could read about habitat loss, species decline and climate change and understandably feel overwhelmed.
The problems are enormous.
Individual action can appear insignificant.
And there is always someone willing to declare that your small contribution is pointless because a larger problem still exists.
Yet collective change doesn't happen without particular actions.
A planted tree isn't an entire forest.
A conservation project isn't a solution to every global crisis.
A child who learns to recognise local wildlife hasn't single-handedly rescued the planet.
But the experience can alter what that child notices, values and eventually does.
The worth of a contribution isn't always measured by whether it solves everything.
Sometimes it lies in becoming part of a process that other people can continue.
That's a more substantial form of hope than simply insisting things will work out.
It requires participation.
A life spent paying attention
Jane Goodall died on 1 October 2025 at the age of ninety-one.
The study she began at Gombe continues. So do the conservation programmes, sanctuaries and youth projects associated with the institute bearing her name.
It's tempting to summarise her life as a story about a brave woman who loved chimpanzees.
She certainly cared about them.
But that description barely touches what made the work significant.
She changed what humans were prepared to notice.
She challenged a scientific culture that could be too quick to dismiss animal individuality.
She demonstrated the importance of long observation and relationships.
She confronted evidence that contradicted her own early expectations about chimpanzee behaviour.
And she eventually recognised that understanding a species was not enough if the world supporting it was being destroyed.
Her work moved from observing individuals, to understanding communities, to protecting ecosystems through relationships with people.
That progression is worth considering.
Not because it proves that all existence is one consciousness.
But because it reveals how much becomes visible when curiosity expands beyond our immediate assumptions.
The Smiling Monad proposes an infinite reality containing countless perspectives.
Goodall's life offers a striking practical question to place alongside that idea.
How many perspectives do we overlook because we have already decided they are unimportant?
The answer may involve animals, people, environments or forms of life we haven't encountered.
And the remedy begins with something surprisingly ordinary.
Pay attention.
Not every mystery requires a particle accelerator.
Some require a notebook, a great deal of patience and the humility to admit that the creature sitting in front of you may know a few things you don't.
Humanity has reached the Moon and built machines that can discuss philosophy.
Remarkable achievements.
Perhaps the next one is remembering that we share this planet with other lives that were never obliged to become human to be worth understanding.
Ben Grey · 14 November 2026
Further reading
- Jane Goodall Institute, Jane Goodall's Story: https://janegoodall.org/jane-goodalls-story/
• Jane Goodall Institute, Gombe research timeline: https://janegoodall.org/jgi-timeline/
• Richard Wrangham, Jane Goodall obituary, Nature (2025): https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03227-w
• Review of sixty years of Gombe chimpanzee research: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/mid/NIHMS1661098/
• Jane Goodall, "Infant Killing and Cannibalism in Free-Living Chimpanzees" (1977): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/564321/
• Research on artificial provisioning and chimpanzee aggression (1974): https://doi.org/10.1016/S0003-3472(74)80056-4
• Jane Goodall Institute, Community-Led Conservation: https://janegoodall.org/community-led-conservation/
• Jane Goodall Institute Tanzania, Roots & Shoots: https://www.janegoodall.or.tz/en/our-approach/strategy/root-shoots
